Reducing VAT Penalty Points: Navigating HMRC's New System

January 31, 2024

The Evolution of HMRC's VAT Penalty System

HMRC's VAT penalty system, grounded in a points-based approach, has undergone significant changes in the past year. As the first wave of new-style fines approaches, it becomes crucial to comprehend the dynamics of reducing penalty points and minimising the risk of financial penalties.

Payments and Returns: Transition from the Old to the New

Under the former VAT surcharge system, late returns and payments triggered default surcharge periods, akin to suspended sentences for financial penalties. This system has been replaced by two distinct structures for late returns and late payments since January 1, 2023. This article primarily delves into the implications of late returns.

Late Returns: The Point-Based Penalty System

For every late return, HMRC assigns penalty points to your VAT record, and once a specific threshold is breached, a £200 fine ensues. The threshold varies - two points for annual accounting scheme users, four for quarterly returns, and five for monthly returns. Notably, points accumulate irrespective of whether HMRC owes you money or if your return indicates no transactions.

Penalty Thresholds and Points Clearance: Unveiling the Conditions

If you incur fines for late returns, an additional £200 penalty is levied for subsequent late returns when your VAT record surpasses the points threshold. However, points aren't eternal; they are wiped off under two conditions:

1. Submitting returns on time for twelve consecutive months from the threshold's end.

2. Ensuring all returns for the preceding two years have been submitted.

Examples Illustrating Points Clearance: Acom Associates and Bcom

Example 1: Acom Associates reaches the four-point threshold in December 2023, incurring a £200 fine. To clear all points, it must submit on-time returns for the next four periods until December 2024, with a clean slate afterwards.

Example 2: Bcom avoids fines by not reaching the four-point threshold in 2023. By submitting on-time returns until 2026, HMRC automatically clears its points after two years, preventing old failures from triggering fines.

Tips and Appeals: Navigating the Penalty Landscape

Businesses can appeal penalty points with a reasonable excuse, such as serious illness or bereavement. Understanding the nuances of the system empowers businesses to strategically navigate the penalty landscape and avoid unnecessary financial burdens.

In conclusion, mastering the intricacies of HMRC's VAT penalty point system is essential for businesses aiming to minimize financial risks and ensure compliance. By aligning with the new rules and strategically managing returns, businesses can navigate the evolving landscape and maintain a clean record.

Do penalties sound too confusing?

Let's talk about it. Get in touch today.

Call us: 0739 809 809


Ready to get started?
Please, get in touch and our expert support team will answer all your questions.
Contact us